Cash Balance Pension Plans

Cash Balance Pension Plans for Business Owners

A cash balance plan lets established business owners make tax-deductible retirement contributions far beyond what a 401(k) alone allows. PlanPerfect designs, administers and keeps these plans compliant – from feasibility and plan design through actuarial certification and annual administration.

What is a cash balance plan?

A cash balance plan is a hybrid retirement plan that combines features of a pension plan and a defined contribution plan such as a 401(k). Each participant earns a hypothetical “account balance,” but unlike most defined contribution plans, the interest credit is set by the plan formula, so promised benefits do not depend on market returns – the employer bears the investment risk. Because a cash balance plan is a defined benefit plan, deductible contributions are determined actuarially and can be significantly higher than the Section 415(c) defined contribution dollar limit, particularly for older owners.

Benefits of a cash balance plan

  • Employer contributions are generally tax-deductible within the limits of IRC Section 404, and benefits accrue tax-deferred.
  • Benefits can accrue rapidly, allowing owners to catch up as retirement approaches; contribution levels increase with age.
  • Higher limits on tax-deductible contributions than a 401(k) plan alone.
  • Combines with a 401(k) profit sharing plan for even larger total contributions.
  • Most cash balance plans are insured, within legal limits, by the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation (plans of professional-service employers with 25 or fewer active participants are generally not covered), and benefits are generally protected from creditors under ERISA.
  • Plan assets are professionally managed as one pooled balance, and investment earnings can reduce future employer contributions.
  • Easy for participants to understand and value, because the benefit is stated as an account balance; plans typically permit lump-sum distributions that can be rolled into an IRA or another employer plan.
  • A meaningful benefit for attracting and retaining talent.

Who a cash balance plan tends to fit

  • Older business owners, partners, sole proprietors and independent contractors with steady income who want to accelerate retirement savings.
  • Highly profitable, closely held businesses: family offices, CPA firms, medical groups and professional service organizations.
  • Owners with steady revenue – cash balance plans require funding over several years, so consistent cash flow matters.

How cash balance plans differ from 401(k) plans

  • Participants are generally not required (or allowed) to contribute their own pay; eligible employees earn benefits automatically.
  • The maximum benefit is calculated differently and, depending on age, can allow much higher annual accruals.
  • The “accounts” are bookkeeping accounts that credit interest at a rate set by the plan formula rather than a guaranteed rate of return; plan assets are not segregated per participant.
  • The company funds the plan and bears the investment risk, and required contribution levels depend on the plan’s funded status.
  • Plans must offer certain annuity options, though lump sums are the most popular choice; benefits may be PBGC-guaranteed.

Considerations before adopting

  • Administration costs are higher (actuarial services, experienced providers, PBGC premiums), and actuarial certification is required each year.
  • Nondiscrimination testing generally applies annually. Combination designs that rely on cross-testing must give each non-highly compensated employee an allocation rate of at least one-third of the highest HCE rate, deemed satisfied at 5% of compensation (Treas. Reg. 1.401(a)(4)-8(b)(1)(vi)); total staff cost depends on workforce demographics.
  • Contributions are required for a number of years and can fluctuate – required amounts are owed even in a down year.
  • Cash balance designs are generally less advantageous for very young owners.

How PlanPerfect helps

PlanPerfect handles feasibility modeling, plan design, actuarial coordination, and ongoing administration and compliance for cash balance and combination plan designs. To talk through whether a cash balance plan fits your business, contact Sheree Tallerman at 949-223-8397 or [email protected].